Garden Approved, Community Angered

The Loma Vista project has nearby residents in an uproar.

Depsite frustration from a number of Seaview Ranch residents, community gardens may soon sprout like weeds around Watsonville.

The Watsonville City Council approved the Community Garden Program Guide at its meeting Tuesday night—which includes a long list of potential garden sites—and gave the go-ahead for green thumbs to break ground on a new community garden on Loma Vista.

The proposal was approved with a 4-2 vote; council members Nancy Bilicich and Emilio Martinez voted no.

It didn't come easy; the Loma Vista garden site has been a point of contention in the city and that was evident at the meeting. More than 15 people addressed the city council about both sides of the issue. Clapping, outcry and residents speaking out-of-turn punctuated the meeting.

"Excuse me, you can't keep commenting," Mayor Eduardo Montesino, who used to live in the neighborhood, scolded the crowd at one point. "... I'm going to have to clear the room if you can't stop the outbursts."

Residents who are short on land but big on home-grown veggies are supportive of the new garden, which will be built on land intended for a park. A total of 71 neighbors representing 65 homes would like the garden to be put in, according to a petition filed with the city, Bob Geyer of the city's Public Works Department said.

Sofia Vasquez Quintero, who lives on nearby La Jolla Street, said there are enough parks in the neighborhood and she supported the garden.

“I don’t know what your yards are, but my yard is small. Very small," she said. "...I would love to have a piece of this. I would love to be a part of this.”

Brandon Marquez of Watsonville told the council he learned how to garden as an elementary school and loved working in the sun with friends, growing food.

“Most importantly is a garden unites and builds up a stronger community, and a stronger Watsonville," Marquez said.

Still, most Seaview Ranch homeowners—including the Homeowners Association itself—came out in force against the garden project. Residents worry about traffic, trash, the safety of their children, the health of the wetlands and the loss of wild land.

"There's very very limited parking on that street, which we struggle with all the time," said Holly Heath, who's on the board of directors of the Seaview Ranch HOA.

Douglas Ow, an 18-year Watsonville resident, lives across the street from the garden. He proposed to his wife at the end of this open space, and hoped he would have a place to come back to and celebrate that moment.

“I think it will be a little different if I’m standing in that place amid tomatoes, cucumbers or watermelons," said Ow, who added he would likely move out of Watsonville because of the garden.

Under the plan, the garden will be organic (pesticides will be banned), Geyer said. It will include 25 plots overseen by a garden manager elected from those who are utilizing the land.

“The community gardens are self-managing, for the most part,” Geyer said.

The garden sits below “Tarplant Hill,” a protected site owned and managed by Watsonville Wetlands Watch, Geyer said. That organization, which aims to protect the Pajaro Valley slough system and educate the public about the unique ecosystem of the coastal marshes, has not taken a stance on the community garden.

“It’s sloping out to the slough … so erosion from the garden is going to end up in the slough just from rain. You’re not going to be able to prevent it," said Watsonville resident Darren Dylan. "This is not an appropriate site for a community garden.”

The proposed garden exceeds the city setback requirement from the wetlands, Geyer added.

Two Patch bloggers wrote about their opposition to the garden, "" and "," a contributor who does not represent the Watsonville Wetlands Watch official views.

Other publicly-owned locations identified as possible sites for community gardens include:

  • an unused city parking lot at Main and Front streets;
  • an alleyway that's been used as a garden in the past at California Street and Palm Avenue;
  • the Davis Street community neighborhood services location;
  • a vacant parcel across from Ramsay Park at Main and Longview streets;
  • a large, vacant piece of property behind center field at Franich Park, 795 Vista Montana;
  • Hazelwood Park, the large area below Rolling Hills Middle School, 297 Herman Ave.;
  • a 2-acre parcel at 195 Airport Blvd, off Roache Road, that's an airport-owned clear zone;
  • 52 Ninth St.

Two private parcels also have been listed as possible garden sites: behind the old courthouse on Freedom Boulevard where the FEMA trailers were set up after the 1989 Loma Prieta Earthquake and at the Pajaro Valley Health Trust off Neilson Road.

Tony Rubio April 30, 2012 at 03:17 AM
You know, the most "telling" comment of all last Tues. was from the young boy who likes to ride his bike on that particular weed patch. He said "...and I don't want bad people from downtown coming over here and writing graffiti or joining in gangs". Out of the mouths of babes. He voiced all of your concerns in a nut shell.
Tony Rubio April 30, 2012 at 03:34 AM
Let me say one more thing...this pristine piece of wetlands is a 1/8 acre patch of weeds crrently inhabited by the very invasive Bristly Ox Tounge and equally invasive Harding Grass, which we have been trying to eliminate from the sloughs for years. Westerly of the proposed garden is a 6' asphalt walking trail. West of that is at least 10' of fairly level ground before you get to the top of the rather long slope that leads down to the slough. there will be no run-off from this garden that affects the slough. It's just another smokescreen. Parking? a non issue. Come out to our garden at All Saints, MI Jardin Verde, and see how many cars are in the lot at any one time. Another smoke screen. Proper notice? 3 weeks not enough? How come I was able to attend all these meetings...as well as the Dillons. Another smoke screen. Park site...not a garden site? Park & Rec commission already voted in favor of the garden. Another smoke screen. It all boils down to what that young boy said..."we don't want bad people from downtown coming here". And you know what Nancy? Why don't you come out as yourself instead of hiding behind that misleading moniker of "wetlandswatchdog". Everyone knows it's you. You aren't as clever as you think.
Cathy P. April 30, 2012 at 02:16 PM
"there will be no run-off from this garden that affects the slough." ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- How do you figure that? Will these gardens not be watered? Will this water not be absorbed into the ground or allowed to pool and then runoff into the slough? Will these gardens not be fertilized (in some way) or pesticides used to ward off pests? And who is going to monitor all of this? The garden at All Saints isn't a problem, so no comparision can be made between the two, apples & oranges. As for "out of the mouths of babes," I wouldn't want the increased traffic, pollution, graffiti, & loitering in my neighborhood either.
Tony Rubio April 30, 2012 at 08:23 PM
Water conservation is one of the city's requirements and hopefully most people will use drip irrigation. Unless somebody leaves a hose running or otherwise intentionally tries to send water into the slough, I really don't think there will be any run-off into the slough at all. And fertilzers, pesticides and herbicides are not allowed. Compost is what willl be used. And why would you think this garden will be any different than Mi Jardin Verde? And why do you think that gardeners will "loiter" or cause pollution or graffiti? It's just nonsense. As for the traffic...like I said, I don't think it's going to be the problem that you anticipate. I believe that most of the plots will go to SVR residents or other nearby residents.
Jennifer Squires June 19, 2012 at 10:02 PM
The garden broke ground Saturday. http://watsonville.patch.com/articles/photos-controversial-community-garden-opens


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »